💬 Discussion

Today’s Russia/Ukraine Update

Monday, Apr 25, 2022

🇺🇦 On Friday, Russia's military officially said it wants to seize all of the Donbas region and southern Ukraine (as far as south as Moldova) to form a land bridge to Crimea as part of "the second stage" of its invasion.

  • Also on Friday, Ukrainian officials said Moscow had captured 42 villages in the Donetsk region over the previous 24 hours.
  • Russian forces killed at least eight people, including a 3-month-old baby, in missile strikes targeting the key port city of Odesa on Saturday, per Ukrainian officials. 
  • Why is Odesa so important? Sea cargo makes up 70% of all of Ukraine's imports and exports, and the port city processes three-quarters of that, according to Bloomberg.
  • Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin met with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in Kyiv yesterday as most of the country celebrated Orthodox Easter; it’s the highest-level visit by US officials since the war began.
  • Russian President Vladimir Putin’s girlfriend, a 39-year-old former Olympian gymnast, was reportedly spared from US sanctions imposed several weeks ago in a last-minute decision for fear it could further escalate tensions between the two countries, per the WSJ.

+The latest news: From the Left | From the Right

See the 360 View

Democratic donkey symbol

Sprinkles from the Left

A poll published last week by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research shows 54% of Americans think Biden has been “not tough enough” in his response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Thirty-six percent think his approach has been about right, while 8% say he’s been too tough.

🚀⏰ Ready, Set, Go: These opinions take 1.74 minutes to read.

As of this week, [sanctions] have made dents in both Russia’s economy and its ability to wage war in Ukraine. As foreign companies have withdrawn operations from Russia, Moscow’s mayor, Sergei Sobyanin, estimated that some 200,000 people there are at risk of losing their jobs, and there’s some evidence that the decision by Europe and the United States to restrict the export of microchips has already affected Russia’s ability to produce and repair tanks. The sanctions have also sent a vital message of support to the Ukrainian people.

It is undeniable that the United States and its allies were — and still are — right to use sanctions to try to end this war.

[But] sanctions alone — at least any sanctions that European countries would be willing to now consider — will not bring Russia to its knees any time soon. As long as Europeans still depend on Russian oil and gas, Russia will be able to depend on significant income from that relationship. The spat over whether gas deliveries will be paid in rubles, as Russia has demanded, only highlights the bind that European countries find themselves in.

The oligarchs who are losing their yachts and the people who are tightening their belts have little sway over the Kremlin. In Russia, with average citizens, Mr. Putin has grist for a loud “I told you so” about the West’s purported longing to bring down Russia

The United States and its allies have been wise in tightening the economic screws on Russia, so long as they bear no illusions about what this can and cannot achieve.

New York Times Editorial Board ($)

To anyone familiar with the Russian war effort and the horror it has unleashed on civilians, it may seem obvious that Russia would be relegated to pariah status globally. But that's not the case: Developing countries, especially, have declined to join in the West's campaign of isolation, as seen most recently in a US-led vote to remove Russia from the UN Human Rights Council. It's true that 93 countries supported the move, but 100 other countries did not (24 opposed, 58 abstained, and 18 did not vote). Even more striking, those 100 countries are home to 76% of the world population…

All of this is to say that the US strategy in Ukraine can bleed Russia but can't save Ukraine. Only a peace deal can do that. In fact, the current approach will undermine economic and political stability throughout the world and could divide the world into pro-NATO and anti-NATO camps… 

The best chance to save Ukraine is through negotiations that bring the world onside. By prioritizing peace instead of NATO enlargement, the US would rally the support of much more of the world and thereby help to bring peace to Ukraine and security and stability for the entire world.

Jeffrey Sachs is a professor and director of the Center for Sustainable Development at Columbia University (published in CNN)
Republican elephant symbol

Sprinkles from the Right

A poll published last week by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research shows 54% of Americans think Biden has been “not tough enough” in his response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Thirty-six percent think his approach has been about right, while 8% say he’s been too tough.

🚀⏰ Ready, Set, Go: These opinions take 1.69 minutes to read.

[The whole situation] underscores the urgency of continuing to supply Ukraine’s military, especially with heavy weapons such as long-range artillery, rocket-launch systems, tanks, fighter jets, and missile defenses. Off-the-shelf weapons stocks are running low, and Ukraine will soon need ammunition and missiles directly from Western military assembly lines.

President Biden announced another $800 million in weapons for Ukraine this week, and Congress will have to appropriate more in the coming weeks. Military officials from 20 countries will meet next week in Germany to assess Ukraine’s needs and coordinate aid. This is useful as long as it doesn’t default to the most risk-averse thinking.

This is the time to give Ukraine all it can handle to press for victory against Russia. The goal is to block Russian advances and inflict such losses that Mr. Putin is forced to reconsider his war aims again. He could escalate and try to draw in NATO more directly, but that carries risks of more severe Russian losses.

Ukraine has paid dearly to protect its homeland in a war it didn’t choose. The West’s interest is in a Ukrainian victory that pushes Russia out and lets its people decide their own destiny. Russia without Ukraine is a much less significant threat to NATO and the U.S.

Wall Street Journal Editorial Board

Russia has long wielded its nuclear weapons coercively, threatening to employ them against Poland and other NATO nations, in response to perfectly reasonable actions, including deployment of defensive systems meant only to intercept incoming missiles. Missile defenses are perceived as threatening by nations that want a free shot at the defender, and Moscow is telling on itself when it protests…

Strategists inside the Trump administration were very concerned about Russia’s threats. Russia’s large arsenal of theater nuclear weapons, none of which are constrained by treaty, dramatically outnumber U.S. theater nuclear weapons. Strategists assessed that Russia was giving nuclear weapons a more prominent role in its military strategy and that it was lowering the “nuclear threshold” — a threshold that no nation has crossed since the United States did to end World War II…

As Russia’s brutal war drags on, the risk of Russian nuclear employment goes up. The Biden administration is of course right to want Russia to end this war and not to escalate, especially not to use nuclear weapons. But wanting is not enough. The Biden administration must make a rapid and obvious course correction and seek to convince Russia that the U.S. and NATO are not intimidated by their nuclear threats, that we have a proportional response on the ready, and that we are willing to employ it in defense of our vital interests. The grave implications of failing to do so cannot be overstated.

Rebeccah Heinrichs; senior fellow at the Hudson Institute (published in National Review)
Share this!

Recent Discussion stories

Discussion
  |  April 22, 2022

Mask On, Mask Off: Which Is It?

⚖️😷 The CDC asked the Justice Department this week to appeal a ruling that lifted the agency’s mandate requiring masks on planes, trains, and other forms of public transportation.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  April 20, 2022

Are US Lawmakers Getting Too Old?

🏛️ Members of Congress on both sides of the aisle raised concerns last week that 88-year-old Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-CA), the oldest sitting US senator, may not be as mentally sharp as she used to be.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  April 13, 2022

Are Covid Restrictions Coming Back?

🦠 This week, Philadelphia became the first major US city to re-introduce its mask mandate in response to an uptick in cases spurred by the omicron BA 2 variant.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More

You've made it this far...

Let's make our relationship official, no 💍 or elaborate proposal required. Learn and stay entertained, for free.👇

All of our news is 100% free and you can unsubscribe anytime; the quiz takes ~10 seconds to complete