💬 Discussion

Are we in an AI bubble?

Monday, Nov 24

Image: PITTI

Massive hype around AI has helped power US stock markets to new all-time highs, with the top AI companies responsible for ~80% of all gains in US stocks in 2025, per a recent estimate.

But investors are growing increasingly concerned that recent AI fever could develop into a more dangerous condition: irritable bubble syndrome.

Last week, every member of the Magnificent 7 biggest companies, except for Alphabet, posted losses amid fears of an AI bubble, with Microsoft (-7%), Amazon (-6%), and Nvidia (-4%) staring down the biggest reductions in stock value.

  • Other major players in the AI industry also saw major declines last week, including Oracle (-11%), AMD (-16%), and Micron (-16%).

There are some positive signs. The AI stock losses came despite a blockbuster earnings report from Nvidia on Wednesday, which revealed 60+% annual increases in sales and profits last quarter. "There's been a lot of talk about an AI bubble," Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang said on the earnings call. "From our vantage point, we see something very different."

The arguments

Along with Huang, many other prominent AI leaders say fears of a bubble are overblown, and that the technology is simply in a major boom cycle due to excitement over its potential.

  • JPMorgan Chase executive Mary Callahan Erdoes on Thursday called the idea of an emerging AI bubble "a crazy concept."
  • "Right now, if you look at demand and supply and what’s going on and multiples against growth, it doesn’t look like a bubble at all to me,” prominent Silicon Valley investor Ben Horowitz said earlier this month.

On the other hand: Last week’s stock market rout indicates a growing number of investors have serious doubts about what’s going on under the AI industry’s hood.

Many experts and analysts note that Silicon Valley is taking on massive amounts of debt on the assumption that massive new revenues from AI will cover the tab.

  • But if the market for AI services was to slow even a little, the situation could quickly turn many of the new, expensive AI data centers—and financed debt—into essentially worthless commodities.
  • Critics also note how the leading AI companies are increasingly buying products, power, and services from one another, driving up their valuations in a circular loop that doesn’t reflect organic demand.

Looking ahead…At the core of the AI bubble debate is one major question: will all the spending on chips and research eventually lead to big enough profits to justify the huge outlays?

Morgan Stanley analysts estimate that Big Tech companies will spend $3 trillion in AI infrastructure investment through 2028, with their own cash flows only projected to cover half of that.

📊 Flash poll: In your opinion, is the US economy in the middle on an AI bubble?

See a 360° view of what pundits are saying →

Democratic donkey symbol

Sprinkles from the Left

  • Some commentators argue the brief useful life of AI chips and generous accounting assumptions underpinning investment in them are causing many to rightly voice concerns of a depreciation tsunami that takes down the stock market.
  • Others contend that it’s reasonable for everyday Americans to worry whether sky-high valuations for AI companies represent a bubble that will burst and wreak havoc on their retirement accounts, but there’s a possibility the AI industry is in a “rational bubble” that rightly reflects its transformational potential.
Republican elephant symbol

Sprinkles from the Right

  • Some commentators argue that economists are notoriously bad at measuring the consequences of transformative technologies in real time, and that many major CEOs will tell you that AI is already transforming America’s economic landscape from the top down.
  • Others contend that many lawmakers in Washington are treating the AI industry as if it’s too big to fail, even as the market sends lukewarm signals that building the tech out at such a large scale is worth the financial risk.
Share this!

Recent Discussion stories

Discussion
  |  November 21, 2025

The Trump admin has a new Russia-Ukraine peace plan

A senior Pentagon official met with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in Kyiv yesterday to outline the framework of a new peace agreement that would end the yearslong Russia-Ukraine war.

Kyle Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  November 19, 2025

Congress votes to release the Epstein files

Yesterday, the House and Senate both overwhelmingly voted to compel the Justice Department to release all of its case files related to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.

Kyle Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  November 17, 2025

Some of America’s top rising country artists are robots

Country music’s transition from Johnny Cash’s “Ring of Fire” to “Ring of Water that Cools Computer Chips” is almost complete.

Kyle Nowak
Read More

You've made it this far...

Let's make our relationship official, no 💍 or elaborate proposal required. Learn and stay entertained, for free.👇

All of our news is 100% free and you can unsubscribe anytime; the quiz takes ~10 seconds to complete