💬 Discussion

Roald Dahl's books got some new edits

Wednesday, Feb 22, 2023

Image: Puffin Books/Penguin

Songs aren’t the only content getting remixed these days – books just rang the doorbell to join the party. New editions of children’s books written by the late UK author Roald Dahl are being edited to remove words that could be deemed offensive to some readers, The Telegraph first reported last week.

📚 Background: The Roald Dahl Story Company (RDSC) controls the rights to all of Roald Dahl’s written works, which include Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, The BFG, Fantastic Mr. Fox, The Witches, James and the Giant Peach, The Twits, and Matilda, among others. And like the jock in every ‘80s teen movie Dahl’s books are quite popular, collectively selling more than 200 million copies to-date.

But recently, the author’s catalog was reviewed by the RDSC and UK publisher Puffin Books – and the pair ultimately decided to alter many previous passages that reference topics like weight, mental health, gender, or race to ensure the “wonderful stories and characters continue to be enjoyed by all children today.”

Some notable examples:

  • Every instance of the word “fat” or “ugly” has been removed across all of Dahl’s books. Ditto goes for most descriptions of objects or people using the words “black” or “white,” as well as passages calling people with mental illness “mad” or “crazy.”
  • Many references to gender have also been removed or altered. Examples include swapping out phrases like “mothers and fathers” for “parents,” removing a passage about how boys’ dreams are different from girls’, and saying a supernatural female’s alter-ego may be working as a “top scientist or running a business” instead of as a “cashier in a supermarket or typing letters for a businessman.”

đŸ—Łïž The public reacts: While there are those who applaud the changes, several high-profile authors have denounced them as unwarranted and potentially dangerous, including Salman Rushdie, Philip Pullman, and a community of 7,500 US writers known as PEN America.

📊 Flash poll: How do you feel about the Roald Dahl Company editing the deceased author’s works to remove some words that could be deemed offensive?

Strongly agree

Agree/Somewhat agree

Neutral

Disagree/Somewhat disagree

Strongly disagree

See a 360° view of what media pundits are saying →

Democratic donkey symbol

Sprinkles from the Left

  • Some commentators argue that the Roald Dahl edits at best add a little balance to the books – but the worst of them actually serve to reinforce prejudices by implying that words like “fat” or occupations like secretaries are something to be embarrassed about.
  • Others contend that the Roald Dahl edits aren’t a sign of “woke culture” gone wild, but are actually a result of capitalism, since the book publishers want to have as wide of a consumer base as possible.
Republican elephant symbol

Sprinkles from the Right

  • Some commentators argue that Roald Dahl’s books were meant to be uncomfortable by design, so the exercise of rewriting parts of those books is not only unnecessary, but contrary to the author’s intent.
  • Others contend that the edits to Roald Dahl books are part of a growing trend in children’s books where everything is getting less specific, more didactic, and more boring.
Share this!

Recent Discussion stories

Discussion
  |  February 17, 2023

Should the US change the minimum age to use social media?

đŸ“đŸ“± On Tuesday, Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) introduced a new bill that would ban all US children under the age of 16 from using social media, joining a similar House measure proposed earlier this month by Rep. Chris Stewart (R-UT).

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  February 15, 2023

A look at the Michigan State mass shooting

đŸ« A 43-year-old gunman opened fire Monday night on the campus of Michigan State University, killing three students and wounding five others before fatally shooting himself off-campus after an hours-long manhunt.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  February 13, 2023

Should Rep. George Santos be removed from Congress?

âœŒïžđŸ“ Late last week, a group of House Democrats announced a resolution to expel Rep. George Santos (R-NY) from the chamber, citing a growing list of fabrications told by Santos while he was running for office last year.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More

You've made it this far...

Let's make our relationship official, no 💍 or elaborate proposal required. Learn and stay entertained, for free.👇

All of our news is 100% free and you can unsubscribe anytime; the quiz takes ~10 seconds to complete