💬 Discussion

America is trying a new form of corporal punishment

Friday, Jan 26, 2024

Image: iStock

Last night, Alabama began carrying out the world’s first judicial execution using nitrogen gas, after a pair of last-minute appeals to the Supreme Court were denied.

  • The condemned prisoner was one of three men convicted in the 1988 murder of a woman whose husband hired them to kill her.

Why it matters: If Alabama’s novel execution is deemed successful, it’s likely that nitrogen gas will be examined by other US states where the death penalty is legal. This is because lethal injection – the most widely-used method of execution – has become increasingly harder to perform following a 2012 EU export ban on such drugs and a recent streak of botched injections.

  • Some experts and rights groups, including the UN Human Rights Council, have criticized Alabama’s decision to use nitrogen gas. They argue the new method is unproven in executions, potentially unsafe for witnesses, and could violate multiple international treaties regarding the care of prisoners.

Big picture: Use of the death penalty in the US has declined considerably this century, falling from a total of 98 executions in 1999 to 11 as of 2021.

But that trend has started to reverse. Total US executions rose to 18 in 2022 – and increased again last year to reach 24, the highest figure in a half-decade.

⚖️ Zoom out: The death penalty is currently legal in 21 US states, and can also be used by the federal government and US military. America is one of 52 countries featuring the death penalty, with three nations – China, Iran, and Saudi Arabia – accounting for 90+% of all executions in 2022.

  • The share of US citizens in favor of the death penalty peaked at 80% in 1994, and has steadily declined over the past three decades to its current rate of 53%, per Gallup polling.

📊 Flash poll: In general, do you support the existence of the death penalty?

See a 360° view of what media pundits are saying →

Democratic donkey symbol

Sprinkles from the Left

  • Some commentators argue that the death penalty should be abolished across America, since it is unfair, unfixable, and it turns states into killers in the name of vengeance against killers – and sometimes mentally ill or innocent folks, too.
  • Others contend that contrary to public opinion, the death penalty doesn’t serve as a deterrent for severe criminal activity, as murder rates are consistently higher overall in the death penalty states than in those without capital punishment.
Republican elephant symbol

Sprinkles from the Right

  • Some commentators argue that the desire for retribution against the worst criminals is inherent to human nature, and politicians who try to go against that will face a steep uphill battle from the public.
  • Others contend that while more criminals deserve capital punishment, available data shows that capital punishment is completely impractical because it doesn’t deter severe crimes – actually the opposite – and is also a financial inconvenience.
Share this!

Recent Discussion stories

Discussion
  |  January 24, 2024

A look at the New Hampshire primaries

🗳️ Former President Trump and President Biden – who ran as a write-in candidate – both cruised to victory in their respective New Hampshire primaries yesterday.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  January 22, 2024

US home sales are at its lowest level this century

🏘️ In 2023, sales of existing US homes fell to the lowest level in nearly 30 yrs due to elevated interest rates and rising prices – but there are signs that home-buying activity is picking back up.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  January 19, 2024

The US labor market is giving mixed signals

💼 While the US labor market has shown surprising resilience in recent months, some indicators have analysts warning that the future outlook isn’t quite as rosy.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More

You've made it this far...

Let's make our relationship official, no 💍 or elaborate proposal required. Learn and stay entertained, for free.👇

All of our news is 100% free and you can unsubscribe anytime; the quiz takes ~10 seconds to complete