💬 Discussion

Recent college grads are finding work outside of their degrees

Friday, Feb 23, 2024

Image: Butch Dill

There’s a saying that a college degree is “just a piece of paper” – and for many Americans, that statement hits close to home.

About half of recent US college graduates work in jobs where their degrees aren’t needed, according to a new study tracking the career paths of 10+ million graduates who entered the job market over the past decade.

The research, from the Strada Education Foundation and Burning Glass Institute, found 52% of four-year college graduates were in non-college-level jobs one year after graduation, and 45% were similarly underemployed a decade later.

The college roadmap to El Dorado

Per the data, what a person studies in college is the No. 1 factor in determining their odds of getting on a college-level career track – more so than race, gender, or specific choice of university.

  • Five years after graduating college, ~75% of US students who majored in a health profession, engineering, or a math-intensive business program (finance, accounting) were working at jobs where their degree is needed.
  • On the flip side, ~40% of students who majored in public safety/security, humanities and cultural studies, or a non-math-intensive business program (management, marketing, HR) were using their degree at their job.

Internships were also crucial to landing a college-level career track. Across all degree programs, the underemployment rate for graduates without at least one internship was consistently 15%-20% higher than graduates with an internship during college.

đŸ’„ The impact: Americans in college-level jobs earn nearly 90% more in their 20s, on average, than people with a high-school diploma as their highest level of education, per US Census Bureau data. By comparison, underemployed college graduates earn an average of 25% more than high-school graduates who didn’t complete college.

📊 Flash poll: To all our readers in the workforce who are college graduates – do you work in a job where your degree is needed?

See a 360° view of what media pundits are saying →

Democratic donkey symbol

Sprinkles from the Left

  • Some commentators argue that federal data shows US students looking to make the most of their time in college should focus on choosing the right fields of study, the right school, and getting an internship, all of which boost their chances of a college-level career track.
  • Others contend that the data shows college is a necessary and valuable pathway for many careers – but a prioritization of careers and the pursuit of meaningful work has surpassed it in terms of value in recent years.
Republican elephant symbol

Sprinkles from the Right

  • Some commentators argue that the way the Bureau of Labor Statistics calculates college graduates’ underemployment rates is fundamentally flawed, and doesn’t factor in many Americans who actually do work jobs that require a college degree.
  • Others contend that it’s a mistake for students and their parents to think that college isn’t necessary, since it makes it easier for graduates to recover from early career struggles, and allows those who are underemployed to move up more easily into higher-paying jobs.
Share this!

Recent Discussion stories

Discussion
  |  February 21, 2024

America is facing a teacher shortage

đŸ§‘â€đŸ« Get out those apples, because maybe 1 per day will make the teachers stay – school districts across America are scrambling to deal with a nationwide shortage of educators for all levels.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  February 16, 2024

What New York’s special election can tell us about November

đŸ›ïžđŸ—łïž Former congressman Tom Suozzi (D) won a special House election to replace former NY Rep. George Santos (R), in a race seen as a bellwether for the upcoming November elections.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More
Discussion
  |  February 14, 2024

America’s gig workers are striking for higher pay

🚘đŸȘ§ It could be difficult finding a ride to/from the airport or ordering food delivery today. Over 100K drivers for Uber, Lyft, and DoorDash are striking in 10 cities to increase their pay.

Kyle Nowak & Peter Nowak
Read More

You've made it this far...

Let's make our relationship official, no 💍 or elaborate proposal required. Learn and stay entertained, for free.👇

All of our news is 100% free and you can unsubscribe anytime; the quiz takes ~10 seconds to complete